Mathura: A fresh controversy has emerged ahead of the grand Braj Holi celebrations in Mathura-Vrindavan, as the President of Shri Krishna Janmabhoomi Trust, Dinesh Sharma, has written a letter in blood to Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath, demanding a ban on the entry of Muslims during the festival. The letter, which alleges that Muslims might “spit on sweets” or “adulterate colors,” has sparked a heated debate across religious and political circles.
Dinesh Sharma, in his letter, appealed to CM Yogi, stating, “Muslims should be banned from entering Braj Holi. These people can spit on sweets. You are the emperor of the hearts of Hindus.” The statement has drawn support from some right-wing groups, while others have strongly opposed it, calling it an attempt to divide society.
The demand has been endorsed by organizations such as the Dharma Raksha Sangh, whose national president, Saurabh Gaur, argued that past incidents, including threats received in Bareilly, justify such preventive measures. “They can create any kind of disturbance by adulterating sweets or colors. We are in danger from their sentiments,” he said.
Saint Atul Krishna Das echoed similar concerns, claiming that “Muslims should not be allowed to enter Holi, not only in Braj but across the entire country.” He further stated that the restriction imposed on Muslims during the Kumbh Mela was a necessary precaution, suggesting a similar approach for Holi.
However, this demand has not gone unchallenged. Maulana Shahabuddin Razvi, the national president of All India Muslim Jamaat, strongly condemned the call for a ban, stating that such actions weaken India’s unity. “These statements raise questions about Hindu-Muslim unity in the country. Such decisions also harm India economically and socially,” he said.
Razvi emphasized that India is known for its diverse culture and religious harmony. “A conspiracy is being hatched to weaken Muslims economically. Hindus and Muslims together will open a front against those who spread hatred in society and weaken the country,” he added, urging people not to fall for divisive rhetoric.
The debate has extended to various religious leaders. Acharya Badrish supported the demand, stating, “The way Jihadis and separatists were kept away from Maha Kumbh, the way they were kept away from Garba in Gujarat and Maharashtra, similarly, Holi is a festival full of love, and they should be kept away from it.” He questioned why those who oppose colors should even participate in Holi celebrations.
On the other hand, several religious scholars and community leaders have warned against communalizing a festival that symbolizes love and unity. Many have pointed out that Braj Holi attracts tourists and devotees from across the world, regardless of their religious background.
This controversy comes at a time when religious harmony in India is under increasing scrutiny. While some groups argue that restricting participation in religious festivals helps maintain tradition, others fear that such measures promote division and hatred.
Social activists and political analysts have expressed concerns that such calls for exclusion could set a dangerous precedent, potentially leading to further segregation in public and cultural spaces. Many have urged authorities to ensure that Holi, known for its spirit of inclusivity, remains a festival open to all.
As the festival approaches, the Uttar Pradesh government has yet to respond to the demands. Whether authorities will heed the call or take steps to defuse tensions remains to be seen.
